Abstract

BARAVALLE, Lorenzo. Wilson's Revenge: A Critique of Analogical Selectionist Accounts of Cultural Evolution. Diánoia [online]. 2013, vol.58, n.70, pp.113-132. ISSN 0185-2450.

The main purpose of this paper is criticize theoretical approaches -here called by analogy, or analogical- which aim to extract Darwinian concepts from a biological substrate to apply them to (partially) different ontological domains. This strategy is adopted by some versions of evolutionary epistemology and, especially, by memetics theory. An argument borrowed from philosophy of mind, namely, the argument of causal exclusion, is used to carry out the critique. The existence of a parallelism between memetics and mental causation will be shown, and it will be argued that any possible characterization of the first in terms of the second implies serious metaphysical and epistemological problems. In the conclusions, with no intention of completeness, some ideas on how to avoid reductionist positions, without taking an analogical posture, will be outlined.

Keywords : sociobiology; evolutionary epistemology; memetics; naturalism; causal exclusion.