SciELO - Scientific Electronic Library Online

 
vol.18 número4A novel lighting design system in Masoumeh with an approach to improving technical and economic conditions índice de autoresíndice de materiabúsqueda de artículos
Home Pagelista alfabética de revistas  

Servicios Personalizados

Revista

Articulo

Indicadores

Links relacionados

  • No hay artículos similaresSimilares en SciELO

Compartir


Journal of applied research and technology

versión On-line ISSN 2448-6736versión impresa ISSN 1665-6423

J. appl. res. technol vol.18 no.4 Ciudad de México ago. 2020  Epub 31-Jul-2021

https://doi.org/10.22201/icat.24486736e.2020.18.4.1188 

Artículos

Banach contraction theorem on fuzzy cone b-metric space

Surjeet Singh Chauhan (Gonder)a 

Vishal Guptab  * 

aDepartment of Mathematics, UIS, Chandigarh University, Gharuan, Mohali, Punjab, India

bMaharishi Markandeshwar (Deemed to be University), Mullana-133207, Haryana, India


Abstract:

In the present paper the notion of fuzzy cone b -metric space has been introduced. Here we have defined fuzzy cone b -contractive mapping, and Banach contraction theorem for single mapping and pair of mappings has been proved in the setting of fuzzy cone b -metric space.

Keywords: Fixed point; fuzzy metric space; fuzzy cone metric space; fuzzy cone b -metric space

2010 MSC: 54H25; 54E15; 54E35; 54A40

1. Introduction

Maurice Frechet introduced the metric space in 1906. Since then it has been generalized by many researchers. The notion of b metric was introduced by Bakhtin (1989) which was further used by Czerwik (1993, 1998) to prove many results.

Definition 1.1. (Czerwik, 1993) Let M be a non empty set and λ1 be a given real number. A function d:M×M[0,) is a b -metric on M if the following conditions hold for all x,y,zM,

dx,y=0iffx=y; (B1)

dx,y=dx,y; (B2)

dx,zλ[dx,y+dy,z]; (B3)

The triplet (M,d,λ) is called b -metric space.

Examples and fixed point theorems related to b metric space are mentioned in (Ansari, Gupta, & Mani 2020; Boriceanu, 2009; Boriceanu Bota, & Petrusel 2010; Shatanawi, Pitea, & Lazovic, 2014).

The concept of b-metric space is broader than concept of metric space, when we take λ=1 in b -metric space then we get metric space.

Huang and Zhang (2007) generalized the concept of metric space by introducing the concept of cone metric space. In the research by Huang and Zhang (2007) real numbers are replaced with an ordered Banach space and some fixed point theorems for non linear mappings are proved. After the work of Huang and Zhang (2007), lot of literature appeared related to the study of cone metric spaces. Details are available (Jankovi’c, Kadelburg, & Radenovi’c, 2011; Latif, Hussain, & Ahmad, 2016; Mehmood, Azam, & Ko’cinac, 2015; Shatanawi, Karapinar, & Aydi,2012).

Zadeh (1965) introduced the concept of fuzzy set theory. After his work many researchers started applying this new concept to classical theories. In particular, Kramosil and Michalek (1975) introduced the new concept fuzzy metric space and proved many results. George and Veeramani (1994) introduced a stronger form of fuzzy metric space. Afterwards, many mathematicians studied fixed point theorems in the related spaces (Chauhan & Utreja, 2013; Chauhan & Kant, 2015; Gupta, Saini, & Verma, 2020; Gupta, & Verma, 2020). Czerwik (1998) introduced b metric space and proved some results. The concept of b metric space is the extension to metric space.

Hussain and Shah (2011) introduced the concept of cone b metric space, which generalizes both b-metric space and cone metric space.

Oner, Kandemire, and Tanay (2015) applied the concept of fuzziness to cone metric space and introduced fuzzy cone metric space as a generalized form of fuzzy metric space given by George and Veeramani (1994). They proved some basic properties and fixed point theorems under this space. We can see related work in (Oner, 2016a, 2016b; Priyobarta, Rohen, & Upadhyay, 2016).

In this paper, we have introduced the concept of fuzzy cone b metric space in the sense of George and Veeramani (1994). Here we combine the notion of cone b metric space with the concept of fuzziness in the sense of George and Veeramani (1994) and proved new version of Banach contraction principle using this concept. We have defined fuzzy cone b contractive mapping and proved the fuzzy cone b -Banach contraction theorem for single mappind as well as the pair of mappings. Other important results which are helpful in this study are (Abbas, Khan & Radenovic 2010; Ali & Kanna 2017: Boriceanu, Bota & Petrusel 2010: Li & Jiang 2014; Turkoglu & Abuloha 2010).

Some more basic definitions which are used directly or indirectly are mentioned below:

Definition 1.2. (Schweizer & Sklar, 1960) The binary operation *:[0,1]×[0,1][0,1] is called continuous t-norm if * satisfies the following conditions for al a,b,c,d0,1,

  1. * is commutative and associative;

  2. * is continuous;

  3. a*1=a,a0,1;

  4. a*bc*dwheneveracandbd;

Example 1.1. Some examples of continuous t-norms are , and *L, which are defined by cd=minc,d,c.d=cd (usual multiplication in [0,1]) and c*Ld=maxc+d-1,0.

Definition 1.3. (George & Veeramani, 1994) The triple Y,N,* is said to be fuzzy metric space if Y is an arbitrary set, * is a continuous t -norm and N is a fuzzy set on Y×Y×0, such that for all a,b,cY and s,t>0, we have

  1. Na,b,t>0;

  2. Na,b,t=1 if and ony if a=b;

  3. Na,b,t=N(b,a,t) ;

  4. Na,c,t+sN(a,b,t)*N(b,c,s);

  5. Na,b,.:0,0,1 is continuous.

Definition 1.4. (Sedghi & Shobe, 2012) Let Y be a non empty set, * a continuous t-norm and let k1 be a given real number. A fuzzy set N in Y×Y×0, is called b -fuzzy metric if for any a,b,cY, and t,s>0, the following conditions hold:

  1. Na,b,0>0;

  2. Na,b,t=1 if and only if a=b;

  3. Na,b,t=N(b,a,t);

  4. Na,c,t+sN(a,b,tk)*N(b,c,sk);

  5. Na,b,.:0,0,1 is continuous.

Throughout this paper B denotes a real a Banach space and θ denotes the zero of B.

Definition 1.5. (Huang & Zhang, 2007) Let Qbe the subset of B. Then Q is called a cone if

  1. Q is closed, non empty, and Qθ;

  2. if c,d[0,) and u,vQ, then cu+dvQ;

  3. if both uQ and -uQ, then u=θ.

For a given cone QB a partial ordering on B via Q is defined by uv if and only if v-uQ. uv stands for u<v and uv, while u<<v stands for v-uint(Q), where int(Q) is the set of all interior points of Q. In this paper, we assume that all cones has non empty interior.

Definition 1.6. (Oner et al., 2015) A three tuple (Y,N,*) is said to be a fuzzy cone metric space if Q is a cone of B, Yis an arbitrary set, * is a continuous t-norm and Nis a fuzzy set on Y2×int(Q) satisfying the following conditions for a,b,cY and t,sint(P),

  1. N(a,b,t)>0 and N(a,b,t)=1 iff a=b;

  2. N(a,b,t)=N(b,a,t);

  3. N(a,c,t+s)N(a,b,t)*N(b,c,s);

  4. Na,b,.:intQ0,1 is continuous.

Definition 1.7. (Oner et al., 2015) Consider a fuzzy cone metric space (Y,N,*),yY and yn be a sequence in Y, then

  • 1. yn is said to be converge to y if for t>>θ and α(0,1) there exists natural number n1 such that N(yn,y,t)>1-α for all n>n1.

We denote it by limnyn=y or yny as n;

  • 2. yn is said to be a Cauchy sequence if for α(0,1) and t>>θ there exists natural number n1 such that N(ym,yn,t)>1-α for all m,nn1;

  • 3. (Y,N,*) is said to be a complete cone metric space if every Cauchy sequence is convergent in Y;

  • 4. yn is said to be fuzzy cone contractive if there exists α(0,1) such that 1N(yn+1,yn+2,t)-1α(1N(yn,yn+1,t)-1) for all tθ,nN.

2. Main results

Definition 2.1 Let Y be a non empty arbitrary set, * is a continuous t-norm, N is a fuzzy set on Y×Y×Int(Q), Q is a cone of B (Real Banach space). A quadruple (Y,N,*,λ) is said to be fuzzy cone b -metric space if following conditions are satisfied for all a,b,cYand t,sIntQ,λ1,

  • FCNB1: N(a,b,t)>0;Na,b,0=0;

  • FCNB2: N(a,b,t)=1forallt>0iffa=b

  • FCNB3: N(a,b,t)=N(b,a,t)

  • FCNB4: N(a,b,t)*N(b,c,s)N(a,c,λ(t+s)),s0

  • FCNB5: Na,b,.:intQ0,1 is continuous and limnN(a,b,t)=1.

Example 2.1: LetB=R2. Then Q=(r1,r2):r1,r20 subset of B, is a normal cone with normal constant k=1.

Let Y=R,a*b=ab and M:X2×intQ0,1, defined by Mx,y,t=1ex-yλt for all x,yXand t0.

  • FCNB1:Mx,y,0=1ex-y0=1e=1=0; M(x,y,t)>0ift>0.

  • FCNB2:Mx,y,t=1 for all t>0 iff x=y. i.e. Mx,y,t=1ex-yλt=1e0=1.

  • FCNB3:Mx,y,t=1ex-yλt=1ey-xλt=My,x,t.

  • FCNB4:st+sλ(t+s), and tt+sλ(t+s), as λ1.

This gives, sλ(t+s) and tλ(t+s), we have λ(t+s)s1 and λ(t+s)t1.

Now, x-zx-y+y-z, we can write, x-zx-yλ(t+s)t+y-zλ(t+s)s, this implies, x-zλ(t+s)x-yt+y-zs, so, one can get ex-zλ(t+s)ex-yt+ey-zs or 1ex-zλ(t+s)1ex-yt+1ey-zs.

Thus, M(x,z,λ(t+s))M(x,y,t)*M(y,z,s).

  • FCNB5: Define f1:IntQ0, such that f1(t)=t=r12+r22and f2:0,0,1,f2(v)=ex-yv.

Then Mx,y,.:IntQ0,1 is composite function of f1 and f2.

Both f1 and f2 are continuous, hence M(x,y,.) is also continuous and limtM(x,y,t)=limt1ex-yt=1.

Definition 2.2: Let(Y,N,*,λ) be a fuzzy cone b -metric space.R:YY be a self mapping. Then R is said to be fuzzy cone b -contractive if there exist α0,1 such that 1N(Rx,Ry,t)-1 α (1N(x,y,t)-1) for x,yY and tθ, where θ denotes the zero of B and α is known as contraction constant of R.

Definition 2.3: Let (Y,M,*,λ) be a fuzzy cone b -metric space and xn be a sequence in Y. Then xn is said to be fuzzy cone b -contractive if 1M(xn+1,xn+2,t)-1 α (1M(xn,xn+1,t)-1) for all tθ, nis natural number,α0,1.

Definition 2.4: Let (Y,M,*,λ) be a fuzzy cone b -metric space.A,B:YY are self mappings. Then mappings AandBare known as fuzzy cone b -contractive ifα0,1 such that 1N(Ax,By,t)-1 α (1N(x,y,t)-1) for tθ, α is called contraction constant of Aand B.

Fuzzy Cone b -Banach Contraction Theorem

Theorem 2.1: Let X,M,*,λbe complete fuzzy cone b -metric space in which fuzzy cone b -contractive sequence is Cauchy andS,TR be fuzzy cone contractive mappings and SXTX. Then S and Thave unique common fixed point.

Proof: Let x0X, define a sequence xn such that x2n+1=Sx2n,x2n+2=Tx2n+1 for n=0,1,2...

First we show that sub sequence x2n is a Cauchy sequence 1M(x2n+1,x2n+2,t)-1=1M(Sx2n,Tx2n+1,t)-1α1M(x2n,x2n+1,t)-1=α1M(Sx2n-1,Tx2n,t)-1α21M(x2n-1,x2n,t)-1,

Continue in this way, we get 1M(x2n+1,x2n+2,t)-1α2n+11M(xo,x1,t)-1.

Then x2n is a Cauchy sequence in Xand Xis complete .

Therefore x2n converges to y for some yX. Then using Theorem 2.10 (Nadaban, 2016) we have, 1M(Sx2n,Tx2n+1,t)-1α1M(x2n+1,x2n+2,t)-1α1M(y,y,t)-1 this gives, 1M(Sx2n,Tx2n+1,t)=1. Thus, Sx2n=Tx2n+1 and therefore Sy=Ty as n.

Hence y is a coincidence point of Sand T.

Now we will prove that yis a fixed point of Sand T.

Since, 1M(Sy,Tx2n,t)-1α1M(y,x2n,t)-1, this gives, 1M(Sy,x2n+1,t)-1 α(1M(y,y,t)-1) as x2ny and Tx2n=x2n+1, thus 1M(Sy,y,t)-10. Hence Sy=y.

For uniqueness, let uis also a fixed point of Sand T, ie. Su=Tu=u.

Therefore, 1M(y,u,t)-1=1M(Sy,Tu,t)-1α1M(y,u,t)-1 ie. (1-α)1M(y,u,t)-10, this gives,M(y,u,t)=1.

Thus y=u. and henceyis a unique common fixed point of Sand T.

Corollary 2.1 (Fuzzy Cone b -Banach Contraction Theorem) Let (X,M,*λ) be a complete fuzzy cone b -metric space in which fuzzy cone b -contractive sequence is Cauchy and S:XXbe a fuzzy cone contractive mapping. Then S has unique fixed point.

Proof. If we put S=Tin Theorem 2.1, we get the result.

Definition 2.5: Let (X,M,*λ) be fuzzy cone b -metric space. A self mapping TonX is called Chauhan-Gupta contraction if it satisfies the following condition for allx,yX,k0 and a,b0,1 suchthat a+b<1,a<1-k, 1M(Tx,Ty,t)-1a1M(x,Tx,t)*M(y,Tx,t)-1+b1M(y,Ty,t)-1+k1minM(x,Ty,t),M(y,Tx,t)-1.

Theorem 2.2: Let(X,M,t,λ) be a complete fuzzy cone b -metric space. Let T:XX is a Chauhan-Gupta contraction given by (1). ThenThas a unique fixed point inX.

Proof: Let x0X and define a sequence xn by xn=Txn-1 for n0. Then by (1), for t0,n1, 1M(Tx,Ty,t)-1a1M(x,Tx,t)*M(y,Tx,t)-1+b1M(y,Ty,t)-1+k1minM(x,Ty,t),M(y,Tx,t)-1. this gives, 1M(xn,xn+1,t)-1=1MTxn-1,Txn,t-1a1Mxn-1,Txn-1,t*Mxn,Txn-1,t-1+b1Mxn,Txn,t-1+k1minMxn-1,Txn,t,Mxn,Txn,t-1 a1M(xn-1,xn,t)*M(xn,xn,t)-1+b1M(xn,xn+1,t)-1+k1minM(xn-1,xn+1,t),M(xn,xn,t)-1a1M(xn-1,xn,t)-1+b1M(xn,xn+1,t)-1+k(0), we get, 1M(xn,xn+1,t)-1a(1-b)1M(xn-1,xn,t)-1

This implies,1M(xn,xn+1,t)-1h1M(xn-1,xn,t)-1hn1M(x0,x1,t)-1, where h=a(1-b)<1 as a+b<1. xn is a fuzzy cone b -contractive sequence and therfore one can getlimnM(xn,xn+1,t)=1 for t0.

Now, for m>nn0, 1M(xn,xm,t)-11Mxn,xn+1,t-1+1Mxn+1,xn+2,t-1+...+1Mxm-1,xm,t-1hn1Mx0,x1,t-1+hn+11Mx0,x1,t-1+...+hm-11Mx0,x1,t-1 =(hn+hn+1+...+hm-1)1M(x0,x1,t)-10 as n.

Thus limnM(xn,xm,t)=1, which gives xn is a Cauchy sequence. The completenes of X, one can say limnxn=u.

Now, 1M(xn+1,Tu,t)-1=1MTxn,Tu,t-1a1Mxn,Txn,t*Mu,Txn,t-1+b1Mu,Tu,t-1+k1minMxn,Tu,t,Mu,Txn,t-1=a1Mxn,xn+1,t*Mu,xn+1,t-1+b1Mu,Tu,t-1+k1minMxn,Tu,t,Mu,xn+1,t-1=a1Mu,Tu,t*Mu,u,t-1+b1Mu,Tu,t-1 +k1minM(u,Tu,t),M(u,u,t)-1, we get,1M(u,u,t)-1b1M(u,Tu,t)-1 for t0and b<1.

Hence u is a fixed point of T.

For uniqueness, let v is another fixed point of T.

1M(u,v,t)-1=1M(Tu,Tv,t)-1a1M(u,Tu,t)*M(v,Tu,t)-1+b1M(v,Tv,t)-1+k1min{Mu,Tv,t,M(v,Tu,t)}-1=a1Mu,u,t*Mv,u,t-1+b1Mv,v,t-1+k1minM(u,v,t),M(v,u,t)-1,implies, 1M(u,v,t)-1a+k1M(v,u,t)-1, where a+k<1.

Thus M(u,v,t)=1 and this gives u=v.

Hence, uis a unique fixed point of T.

3. Conclusions

In this article, we Introduced the idea of fuzzy cone b -metric space and the fuzzy cone b-contractive mapping has been defined. Also, the Banach contraction theorem has been proved in the setting of fuzzy cone b metric space. Based on the results in this paper, interesting researches may be prospective. In the future study, one can establish the integral version of fixed point theorem in this space and can also think of establishing some new fixed point results in fuzzy cone b -metric space. The work presented here is likely to provide a ground to the researchers to do work in different structures by using these conditions.

References

Abbas, M., Khan, M.A. & Radenovic, S. (2010). Common coupled fixed point theorem in Cone metric spaces for w-compatible mapping, Appl.Math.Comput, 217(1), 195-202. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.amc.2010.05.042 [ Links ]

Ali, A.M. & Kanna, G.R. (2017). Intuitionistic fuzzy cone metric spaces and fixed point theorems, International Journal of Mathematics and its Applications, 5(1), 25-36. [ Links ]

Ansari, A. H., Gupta, V. & Mani, N. (2020). C-class functions for generalized cyclic contractive mappings in b-metric spaces, Journal of Applied Mathematics, Statistics and Informatics, In press. [ Links ]

Bakhtin, I.A. (1989). The contraction mapping principle in quasi-metric spaces, Funct. Anal. Unianowsk Gos. Ped. Inst., 30, 26-37. https://doi.org/10.12691/tjant-6-2-2. [ Links ]

Boriceanu, M. (2009). Strict fixed point theorems for some multivalued operators in b metric spaces, International J.Modern Math, 4, 285-301. https://doi.org/10.12691/tjant-2-1-5. [ Links ]

Boriceanu, M., Bota, M. & Petrusel, A. (2010). Multivalued fractals in b metric spaces, Central Europen Journal of Mathematics, 8(2), 367-377. https://doi.org/10.2478/s11533-010-0009-4 [ Links ]

Boriceanu, M., Petrusel, A. & Rus, I.A. (2010). Fixed point theorems for some multivalued generalized contraction in b metric spaces, International J.Math.Statistics, 6(S10), 65-76. [ Links ]

Chauhan(Gonder), S.S. & Kant, R. (2015). Tripled Common Fixed point theorem in M-fuzzy metric space, Engineering Mathematics Letters, 2015 (6), 1-11. [ Links ]

Chauhan(Gonder), S.S. & Utreja, K. (2013). A Common Fixed point theorem in fuzzy 2-Metric space, Int.J.Contemp.Math.Science, 8(2), 85-91. http://dx.doi.org/10.12988/ijcms.2013.13009 [ Links ]

Czerwik, S. (1993). Contraction mapping in b-metric space, Acta Mathematica et Informatica Universitatis Ostraviensis , 1(1), 5-11. [ Links ]

Czewik, S. (1998). Non liner set-valued contraction mapping in b-metric spaces, Atti.Sem.Math.Fig.Univ.Modena, 46(2), 263-276. [ Links ]

George, A & Veeramani, P. (1994). On some results in fuzzy metric space, Fuzzy Sets and Systems, 64(3), 395-399. https://doi.org/10.1016/0165-0114(94)90162-7. [ Links ]

Gupta, V., Saini, R.K & Verma, M. (2020). Fixed point theorem by altering distance technique in complete fuzzy metric spaces, International Journal of Computer Aided Engineering and Technology, 13(4), (2020), 437-447. https://doi.org/10.1504/IJCAET.2020.10029303 [ Links ]

Gupta, V. & Verma, M. (2020). Common fixed points using (ψ, ϕ)- type contractive maps in fuzzy metric spaces, Journal of Applied Research and Technology, 18(1), 27-33. https://doi.org/10.22201/icat.24486736e.2020.18.1.930 [ Links ]

Huang, L. & Zhang, X. (2007). Cone metric spaces and fixed point theorem in contractive mapping, Journal of Mathematical Analysis and Applications, 332(2), 1468-1476. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jmaa.2005.03.087 [ Links ]

Hussain, N. & Shah, M.H. (2011). KKM mapping in cone b-metric spaces, Comput.Math.Appl, 61 , (4), (2011), 1677-1684. http://doi.org/10.1016/j.camwa.2011.06.004 [ Links ]

Jankovi’c, S., Kadelburg, Z. & Radenovi’c, S. (2011). On cone metric spaces: a survey, Nonlinear Anal, 74(7), 2591-2601. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.na.2010.12.014 [ Links ]

Kramosil, O. & Michalek, J. (1975). Fuzzy metric and statistical metric spaces, Kybernetika, 11(5), 336-344. [ Links ]

Latif, A., Hussain, N. & Ahmad, J. (2016). Coincidence points for hybrid contractions in cone metric spaces, Journal of nonlinear and convex analysis, 17(5), 899-906. [ Links ]

Li, Z. & Jiang, S. (2014). Quasi-contractions restricted with linear bounded mappings in cone metric spaces, Fixed Point Theory Appl, 2014(87 ), 1-10. https://doi.org/10.1186/1687-1812-2014-87 [ Links ]

Mehmood, N., Azam, A. & Ko’cinac, L.D.R. (2015). Multivalued fixed point results in cone metric spaces, Topology Appl, 179 , ( 2015 ), 156-170. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.topol.2014.07.011 [ Links ]

Nadaban, S. (2016). Fuzzy b-metric spaces, International Journal of Computers Communications & Control, 11(2), 273-281. https://doi.org/10.15837/ijccc.2016.2.2443 [ Links ]

Oner, T. (2016a). On the metrizability fuzzy cone metric space, Int.j.Eng.Technol.Manag.Appl.Sci, 2(5), 133-135. http://doi.org/10.22436/jnsa.008.05.13 [ Links ]

Oner, T. (2016b). On some results in fuzzy cone metric space, Int. J.Adv.Comput.Eng.Network, 4, ( 2016 ), 37-39. [ Links ]

Oner, T., Kandemire, M.B. & Tanay, B. (2015). Fuzzy cone metric spaces, J.Nonlinear Sci.Appl, 8(5), 610-616. http://doi.org/10.22436/jnsa.008.05.13 [ Links ]

Priyobarta, N., Rohen, Y. & Upadhyay, B.B. (2016). Some fixed point results in fuzzy cone metric spaces, Int, J.Pure Appl.Math, 109(3), 573-582. http://doi.org/10.12732/ijpam.v109i3.7 [ Links ]

Schweizer, B. & Sklar, A. (1960). Statistical metric spaces, Pacific Journal of Mathematics, 10(1), 314-334. [ Links ]

Sedghi, S. & Shobe, N. (2012). Common fixed point theorems in b-fuzzy metric spaces, Nonlinear Function Analysis and Application, 17(3), 349-359. [ Links ]

Shatanawi, W., Karapinar, E. & Aydi, H. (2012). Coupled coincidence points in partially ordered cone metric spaces with a c-distance, J. Appl. Math, 2012, 1-15. https://doi.org/10.1155/2012/312078 [ Links ]

Shatanawi, W., Pitea A. & Lazovic, R. (2014). Contraction conditions using comparison function on b metric spaces, Fixed Point Theory Appl , 2014(135), 1-11. https://doi.org/10.1186/1687-1812-2014-135 [ Links ]

Turkoglu, D. & Abuloha, M. (2010). Cone metric spaces and fixed point theorems in diametrically contractive mappings, Acta. Math. Sin.-English Ser., 26, 489-496. https://doi.org/10.1007/s10114-010-8019-5 [ Links ]

Zadeh, L.A. (1965). Fuzzy sets, Inform.Control, 8(3), 338, 353. https://doi.org/10.1016/S0019-9958(65)90241-X [ Links ]

Peer Review under the responsibility of Universidad Nacional Autónoma de México.

Received: October 11, 2019; Accepted: May 21, 2020; Published: August 31, 2020

Corresponding author. E-mail address: vishal.gmn@gmail.com (Vishal Gupta).

Creative Commons License This is an open-access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License